Kalen DeBoer Deserves More Time: Why Alabama Football Fans Need to Trust the Process

NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...

When Kalen DeBoer accepted the head coaching job at Alabama, he wasn't just taking over one of the biggest brands in college football. He was stepping into the shoes of the greatest coach the sport has ever seen.

Think about that for a second.

Not just a successful coach. Not just a national champion. The greatest college football coach college football has ever known. And somehow, less than two seasons into his tenure, there are already people questioning whether he's "the guy."

I think we're asking the wrong question.

The question shouldn't be whether Kalen DeBoer is Nick Saban. The question should be why we're expecting anyone to be. Because the truth is, no one ever will. Not Kalen DeBoer. Not Kirby Smart. Not Dabo Swinney. Not Ryan Day. Not anyone.

Nick Saban wasn't simply one of the greatest coaches in college football history. He fundamentally changed the sport. What he built in Tuscaloosa wasn't normal, and honestly, it may never be duplicated. For nearly two decades, Alabama fans watched excellence become the expectation. National championships became realistic goals every single season. SEC titles felt routine. Ten-win seasons somehow felt disappointing. That wasn't normal. That was Nick Saban.

The problem is that somewhere along the way, many fans stopped appreciating how extraordinary those years really were and instead began treating them as the baseline for every coach who follows.

That's simply not fair.

Kalen DeBoer isn't just replacing a successful football coach. He's replacing the greatest to ever do it. That's an impossible assignment before you even factor in everything else that has changed about college football.

Let's be honest. There was never going to be a perfect hire after Nick Saban retired. It didn't exist. If Alabama had hired Kirby Smart, people would've compared him to Saban. If it had been Steve Sarkisian, Lane Kiffin, Dan Lanning, Dabo Swinney or anyone else, those comparisons would've never stopped. That's the burden of following a legend.

But following a legend doesn't mean becoming one overnight.

One thing I don't think gets talked about nearly enough is how different Nick Saban's situation was when he arrived in Tuscaloosa. People remember what Alabama became under him, but they've forgotten what Alabama looked like before him.

When Saban took over in 2007, Alabama wasn't coming off a dynasty. The program had dealt with NCAA sanctions, scholarship reductions, coaching turnover and years of inconsistency. He wasn't inheriting a machine that had just dominated college football for nearly two decades. He was hired to rebuild Alabama into what it once was.

And despite everything we remember today, his first season ended 7-6.

Nobody was calling him the greatest coach in college football after one year. Nobody expected six national championships before he'd coached his first game. The dynasty was built brick by brick.

Now compare that to Kalen DeBoer.

He's walking into a program where the expectation isn't simply to win. The expectation is to continue the greatest dynasty college football has ever seen without missing a beat. Fans aren't just asking him to replace Nick Saban. Many are expecting him to be Nick Saban.

That's an impossible standard because Nick Saban wasn't even Nick Saban overnight.

Then there's something else people seem to overlook.

Kalen DeBoer isn't coaching in the same era Nick Saban inherited.

College football has changed more over the last few years than it had over the previous several decades.

When Nick Saban built Alabama into a dynasty, there was no transfer portal allowing players to leave every offseason with immediate eligibility. There weren't multi-million-dollar NIL deals changing recruiting overnight. Coaches weren't rebuilding their rosters every December because college football had essentially become free agency.

By the time NIL and unrestricted transfers became part of the sport, Nick Saban had already built the foundation. He already had championship culture. He already had national titles. He already had the infrastructure in place.

Kalen DeBoer doesn't get that advantage. He's trying to build while navigating the most chaotic era college football has ever seen. That's not making excuses for him. That's simply acknowledging reality.

And despite those challenges, what exactly has he done to make people believe Alabama is headed in the wrong direction?

Elite recruits continue committing to Alabama. Five-star quarterbacks still want to play in Tuscaloosa. The recruiting classes remain among the best in the country. Players are staying when countless programs across the nation are watching their rosters get picked apart by the transfer portal.

That doesn't happen by accident.

That happens because recruits believe in Kalen DeBoer's vision. It happens because parents believe in him. It happens because players inside the program believe in him.

Sometimes I think we've become so obsessed with immediate results that we've forgotten how championship programs are actually built. Ironically, one of Nick Saban's greatest teachings was "The Process."

Trust the process. Focus on the next step. Don't become consumed with the outcome.

Yet now, it feels like some Alabama fans want to skip the process entirely.

They want instant championships.

Instant perfection.

Instant dominance.

That's not how this works.

Culture isn't built in six months. Leadership isn't established overnight. Trust takes time. Championships take time. Even the greatest dynasty in college football history took time.

I also think it's worth remembering that Kalen DeBoer didn't accidentally end up at Alabama.

Greg Byrne didn't throw a dart at a coaching board and hope for the best.

He hired someone who has won everywhere he's been. Sioux Falls. Fresno State. Washington. Every stop along the way, DeBoer has inherited programs and elevated them. He's developed quarterbacks. He's won conference championships. He took Washington to the national championship game. That résumé didn't disappear the moment he stepped onto Alabama's campus.

Winning has followed him throughout his career.

Does that guarantee he'll win multiple national championships at Alabama?

Of course not. Nothing guarantees that. Not even Nick Saban could guarantee championships. But it does mean he's earned the opportunity to build this program his way. I also think Alabama fans sometimes underestimate the pressure Kalen DeBoer faces every single day.

Imagine showing up to work knowing the person before you is universally considered the greatest person who has ever done your job.

Every decision gets analyzed. Every recruiting battle becomes national news. Every loss becomes a crisis. Every win is expected. Every championship is demanded.

There may not be a more difficult coaching position in America.

Yet through all of it, DeBoer has remained steady.

He hasn't blamed NIL. He hasn't blamed the transfer portal. He hasn't blamed the players. He hasn't lashed out at fans or the media. He's simply gone back to work.

That tells me a lot about the kind of leader he is.

Here's another thought. Imagine being one of Alabama's top recruiting targets. You're scrolling social media after a visit to Tuscaloosa. Instead of seeing excitement about the future, you see portions of the fanbase criticizing its own head coach after every recruiting miss or every close game. You see people wanting change before the foundation has even been built.

What message does that send?

Alabama has always prided itself on having one of the greatest fanbases in college football. This is the moment to prove it. Support doesn't mean lowering expectations. Support means understanding that building something sustainable takes time.

I keep coming back to one simple thought.

If someone replaced us tomorrow at our job, would we want to be judged against the greatest employee who ever lived after only a year or two?

Of course not. We'd want time. We'd want grace. We'd want the opportunity to prove ourselves. Why shouldn't Kalen DeBoer deserve the same?

This story hasn't been written yet. We're trying to decide the ending before we've even reached the middle chapters. Maybe Kalen DeBoer wins multiple national championships. Maybe he wins one. Maybe he never does. None of us knows. But I do know this: He deserves the opportunity to find out without being measured against a standard no coach in the history of college football could realistically meet.

I've been an Alabama fan my entire life. Like everyone else, I want championships. I want SEC titles. I want College Football Playoff appearances. Those expectations should never disappear because this is Alabama. But there's a difference between having championship expectations and having unrealistic expectations.

Holding Alabama to a championship standard is fair.

Expecting Kalen DeBoer to become Nick Saban in less than two years isn't.

Nick Saban changed Alabama forever. Nothing will ever erase what he accomplished, and no one should ever diminish it. But if we spend every Saturday looking backward, we may never fully appreciate what could be waiting ahead.

College football has always been about new chapters. New leaders. New teams. New legacies.

Kalen DeBoer doesn't need to be the next Nick Saban. There will never be another Nick Saban. He simply needs the opportunity to become the first Kalen DeBoer.

And maybe, just maybe, if Alabama fans show him the same patience, support, and belief that every great coach needs to build something lasting, we'll look back years from now and wonder why we were ever so quick to doubt him.

After all, if Nick Saban taught us anything during his 17 seasons in Tuscaloosa, it was this: don't become so consumed with the outcome that you lose sight of the process.

It seems fitting that the greatest way Alabama fans can honor what Saban built is by doing the very thing he preached for nearly two decades.

Trust the process.

Trust the work.

And give Kalen DeBoer the chance to write his own story.

Roll Tide. 

More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos