Why a 20–team College Football Playoff expansion deserves more consideration
NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...
Why a 20–team College Football Playoff expansion deserves more consideration originally appeared on The Sporting News.
Add The Sporting News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
Is the 20-team College Football Playoff the right compromise for more expansion?
ESPN.com's Heather Dinich reported no decision was made on the future of the College Football Playoff. Leaders continue to explore an expansion to 24 teams, and a new number – 20 – briefly became a talking point on Monday. The committee has until Dec. 1 to decide whether the field would expand for 2027.
Given the choice between 24 and 20 – maybe the CFP leaders should give that 20-team format more consideration.
A 20-team field isn't better than the 12-team format or a 16-team format, which got lost in the incremental expansion shuffle. It is, however, more palatable than a bloated 24-team format which has been the sales mission from Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti this offseason. The commissioners and coaches seem to be on board with that plan – but fans aren't exactly clamoring for doubling the field after just two years.
The 20-team format does have one potential hook. Four play-in games could make this work if they sell the play-in games right.
MORE: How CFP will work in 2026 and beyond
How a 20-team format would potentially work
The plan likely would include four play-in games before a first round of 16 teams in the College Football Playoff. Using last year's final CFP rankings and this year's CFP parameters, this is what the 20-team field would have looked like:
Play-in games
No. 13 Texas (at-large) vs. No. 20 Duke (ACC champ)
No. 14 Vanderbilt (at-large) vs. No. 19 Tulane (G6 champ)
No. 15 Utah (at-large) vs. No. 18 Michigan (at-large)
No. 16 USC (at-large) vs. No. 17 Arizona (at-large)
Remember, under the new CFP format the four Power 4 conference champions will get in the playoff – and that was an unranked, five-loss Duke team last season. The highest-ranked Group of 6 schools also will make the field.
Using last year's rankings, No. 19 Virginia would be left out, but they might actually be in because in a 20-team format we likely will eliminate the ACC championship game.
That is the selling point. Those four play-in games would be a substitute for conference championship weekend.
Is it a true sweetener? Would you watch those four games with the same fervor as the SEC championship game – which was Georgia vs. Alabama last year – or the Big Ten championship game – which was a No. 1 vs. No. 2 matchup between Ohio State and Indiana?
I would – but this might not be the popular opinion. In this 12-team format, the participants in the SEC and Big Ten championship games are almost certain to make the CFP anyway. I watch the ACC and Big 12 championship games with a little more interest.
That play-in weekend looks pretty cool – especially the Michigan-Utah matchup. Group of 6 schools would have a better chance of pulling off some upsets. Margin of victory would be less of a topic of conversation, and maybe the NFL will back off a little bit with scheduling on top of these games.
It looks fun, and this is an idea the Power 4 commissioners should explore a little more instead of 24 teams.
MORE: SN's 2026 Preseason All-America team
How first-round games would work
Would the CFP re-seed after the play-in games so the lowest-seeded team would play the No. 1 seed in the first round? If not, then this is what the first round would look like after the play–in games:
First-round games in 20-team format
No. 1 Indiana vs. No. 16 USC/No. 17 Arizona
No. 8 Oklahoma vs. No. 9 Alabama
No. 4 Texas Tech vs. No. 13 Texas /No. 20 Duke
No. 5 Oregon vs. No. 12 BYU
No. 3 Georgia vs. No. 14 Vanderbilt/No. 19 Tulane
No. 6 Ole Miss vs. No. 11 Notre Dame
No. 2 Ohio State vs. No. 15 Utah/No. 18 Michigan
No. 7 Texas A&M vs. No. 10 Miami
This looks like any given bracket in March Madness, which added four more play-in games to expand the tournament field to 76. While that was met with resistance in basketball, these play-in games could be good for college football.
This looks like every team that had a case to be in the College Football Playoff last season. Who doesn't want to see that 3-14 game between Texas Tech and Texas, preferably in Lubbock? This gets you one step closer to Ohio State vs. Michigan in the CFP – which would add a new level to The Game.
MORE: Order SN's 2026 College Football Preseason Magazine today!
Would a 20-team CFP work?
Look at that 20-team field again. It includes seven SEC teams, five Big Ten teams, four Big 12 schools, two ACC schools, one Group of six school and, of course, Notre Dame. Virginia, Houston, Georgia Tech and Iowa are the first four out. The Cavaliers, Cougars and Yellow Jackets were three-loss teams. Iowa was a four-loss team. There will be three-loss at-large teams in the 20-team CFP – but this means four-loss teams would be a rare occurrence. We can lean on strength-of-schedule metrics to sort these teams out, but it means the regular season still has some value.
We would spend the final two weekends arguing about the tenants of whether those four teams belong, but no four-loss teams are in the playoff. That's also way more palatable, too.
Let's tease this format one more time using this year's preseason Coaches Poll as a guide. Here is what we would get this year:
Play-in games
No. 13 LSU vs. No. 20 Boise State*
No. 14 USC vs. No. 19 Washington
No. 15 BYU vs. No. 18 Tennessee
No. 16 Michigan vs. No. 17 Penn State
First round
No. 1 Ohio State vs. No. 16 Michigan/No. 17 Penn State
No. 8 Texas A&M vs. No. 9 Oklahoma
No. 4 Texas vs. No. 13 LSU/No. 20 Boise State
No. 5 Notre Dame vs. No. 12 Texas Tech
No. 3 Georgia vs. No. 14 USC/No. 19 Washington
No. 6 Indiana vs. No. 11 Alabama
No. 2 Oregon vs. No. 15 BYU/No. 18 Tennessee
No. 7 Miami vs. No. 10 Ole Miss
Boise State – which did not crack the Top 25 but is the highest-ranked Group of 6 team – gets in at SMU's expense. The Mustangs are among the first four out with Utah, Iowa and Clemson. The SEC has eight teams, and the Big Ten has seven teams. The Big 12 has two, the ACC has one and we have Group of 6 and Notre Dame. It's virtually the same as last year.
Ohio State-Michigan is in play in the Round of 16. Is this perfect? Of course not. But it's better than 24 – so why not discuss it a little more?
More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos