Alabama vs Florida State Rematch to Test the Tide’s Offseason Fixes

Alabama vs Florida State returns Sept. 19 with last year’s mess still lingering. Alabama entered Tallahassee ranked eighth and left with a 31-17 loss. The defeat dropped it 13 AP poll spots and followed the Tide all the way into December.

You can call the rematch a revenge game if you want, but the bone of contention here is whether Alabama learned anything expensive enough to remember. Last season’s veterans had the experience, a proven line, and playoff expectations. However, none of that stopped Florida State from exposing the same problems Alabama spent months trying to fix.

The rematch turns on what the loss cost, how the committee treated it, and what Alabama changed. It also fed the broader program direction debate that followed Alabama into the winter. The roster is younger now, which sounds like the wrong cure until you remember what the older group did.  Consider the numbers. Alabama had more experience last August and still lost the rushing fight by 143 yards.

Alabama arrived in 2025 with the kind of experience normally sold as insurance against an opening day ambush. CBS Sports counted 14 returning starters, including six on offense and eight on defense. For one drive, the script behaved. Alabama marched 75 yards over 16 plays and took a 7-0 lead. Florida State then scored 24 consecutive points and turned the afternoon into a line-of-scrimmage audit.

The Seminoles rushed for 230 yards, while Alabama managed 87 behind an experienced offensive line. You cannot call that imbalance a fluke. Ty Simpson threw for 254 yards and two touchdowns, but Alabama never controlled the game underneath. Head coach Kalen DeBoer captured the larger problem after the game. “We can’t play on our heels,” he told reporters. Alabama spent too much of that afternoon reacting to Florida State’s pace, movement and physicality.

The polls reacted faster, though. The AP dropped Alabama from No. 8 to No. 21, and that’s its lowest ranking in over a decade. The Coaches Poll moved the Tide from eighth to twentieth, which is the cleaner version of last September’s sudden fall from grace. Florida State’s 5-7 finish made the loss age badly. Still, the Seminoles later led the ACC in total offense and rushing offense. Florida State averaged 472.1 total yards and 218.7 rushing yards.

College football has a cruel filing system. Bad September losses stay attached to December resumes. Alabama recovered anyway, beating Georgia, Vanderbilt, Missouri, and Tennessee before reaching No. 4 in the committee’s first two rankings. Then came a home loss to Oklahoma and a 28-7 SEC Championship loss to Georgia. Alabama entered Selection Day at 10-3 with a resume containing elite wins and one really enormous September stain. The committee kept Alabama at No. 9. CFP chair Hunter Yurachek explained why after the final rankings. “Alabama’s schedule strength was the highest of any team in the top 11,” he said.

The committee still included Alabama, while the opener had already removed valuable margin from its resume. At No. 9, Alabama had to visit No. 8 Oklahoma because the higher first-round seed hosted. The Tide won 34-24, then lost 38-3 to Indiana in the quarterfinal. You cannot assign a home playoff game to a hypothetical. Still, one fewer loss changes every later argument before the committee ever opens the resume.

Here is the uncomfortable part of all of this. Alabama enters this rematch with less experience. Using the same returning-starter measure this time, CBS Sports counts only seven returning starters for 2026, which is half last season’s number. The offensive line shows the turnover most clearly. Michael Carroll is its only returning starter, while second-year Keelon Russell takes over at quarterback. Russell attempted only 15 college passes last season before winning the job over Austin Mack this August.

The spring quarterback competition carried into fall, which means the offense spent months preparing two possible starters. Russell now gets the controls with a passing game still featuring Ryan Williams as its most important returning target. Consider the numbers before you blame youth. Alabama entered Tallahassee with experience and still lost the rushing fight 230-87. Its ground game later finished 125th nationally at 104.1 yards per game.

The failure of last season redefined this offseason. DeBoer hired offensive line coach Adrian Klemm and rebuilt four starting spots. After Alabama’s second fall scrimmage, DeBoer said: “The run game has continued to improve.” Alabama vs Florida State arrives after an offseason built around the ground-game weakness exposed in Tallahassee. September now tests whether those repairs will eventually hold. Florida State did some renovating as well. Head coach Mike Norvell promoted offensive coordinator Tim Harris Jr. after Gus Malzahn retired in February.

The quarterback changed from Tommy Castellanos to Ashton Daniels. Meanwhile, the basic stress remains familiar because Daniels arrived with 23 career starts and 1,397 career rushing yards. Four Alabama defensive starters return, including Bray Hubbard, who intercepted four passes and forced three fumbles last season. That group cannot treat quarterback movement like a new problem.

The setting favors Alabama more than last year’s opener did. Bryant-Denny gets the rematch at 2:30 p.m. CT on ABC after Alabama opens against East Carolina and Kentucky. The calendar offers one small annoyance, though. Florida State plays SMU on Monday, Sept. 7, then gets 12 days to reset before Tuscaloosa. Alabama returns from Kentucky on the standard seven-day turn. Honestly, this is the kind of scheduling wrinkle fans notice after last year’s opener made them suspicious of everything.

The younger roster can outperform last year’s veterans by correcting three specific failures. A functional run game and disciplined quarterback defense would make Alabama better equipped this time. Last September is long gone. Alabama can make sure it never has to explain the same lesson twice. If those changes appear, the 2025 loss then becomes a useful scar tissue. Another failure would inevitably make September expensive all over again.

Main Image: Melina Myers-Imagn Images