‘One of the Most Flawed, Incoherent Arguments the NCAA Ever Made’ — CFB World Reacts to Oversight Committee’s ‘Ridiculous’ Michigan-WMU Decision
NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...
The NCAA finally admitted what Western Michigan had spent more than a week arguing: the final sequence of its season opener against Michigan was handled incorrectly.
The Michigan Wolverines still own a 13-12 win over the Western Michigan Broncos, but the FBS Oversight Committee said Wednesday that replay protocol was not followed before officials restored one second and allowed Bryce Underwood to throw the game-winning Hail Mary to JJ Buchanan.
The committee also said that, had the proper protocol been followed, the outcome would have been different, but added that it cannot overturn the game’s result.
CFB World Rips NCAA’s Michigan-Western Michigan Ruling
That combination, admitting the error while leaving the result untouched, triggered another wave of criticism.
One X user wrote, “This is one of the most flawed, incoherent arguments the NCAA has ever made.”
The same criticism also targeted the clock hierarchy itself, with the fan arguing that the NCAA was effectively choosing the television clock over the in-stadium clock seen by players, coaches and officials.
247Sports reporter David Eickholtremarked, “So… this is insane. And those officials shouldn’t be allowed near a college football game again.”
PREDICT THE CFB SEASON:PFN’s Free CFB Playoff Predictor
Another X usercompared the situation to professional wrestling, writing, “No one wants to say it, but this is essentially what the WWE has been doing with their results for decades. Everyone sees the cheating, but since the ref didn’t catch it, the result is carved in stone.”
OutKick reporter Trey Wallacehighlighted the contradiction in the ruling: “Had the protocols been followed, the outcome of the game would have been different,” before noting that the committee still said it lacked authority to overturn the contest.
Trey Wallaceadded, “Do the right thing for once.”
The NCAA’s admission of an officiating mistake did little to quiet the criticism surrounding its decision.
Why Michigan’s Win Still Stands
The NCAA cited Rules 1-1-3-b and 5-2-9, which make the score final once the referee declares the game over and prevent changes after the period ends.
The committee therefore said it could not grant the Mid-American Conference’s request to overturn the result.
The controversy centered on which clock replay officials were supposed to use. The NCAA said replay reviews involving restored time should use the embedded game clock in the program feed, with the broadcast graphic used if that clock is unavailable.
The Big Ten replay crew instead relied on a different clock feed before restoring one second.
That extra snap became Buchanan’s 47-yard touchdown catch. Without it, Western Michigan would have won 12-7.
Theoriginal controversy had already followed Michigan into Week 2, but the Wolverines responded by beating Oklahoma 17-10. Their defense now owns an 82.8 PFN Defense Impact grade, good enough for No. 23 in the nation.
This article originally appeared on Pro Football Network.
More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos