What Do We Know So Far?
NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...
There are, broadly, two ways to think about football. One is more analytics-driven, digging into the stats and numbers that quantify each team’s on-field performance. The other is narrative based, taking a team’s history, identity, and the beloved “eye test” into account as part of a story about what’s going on with a particular team in any given year. In these articles, I try to do a little from Column A and a little from Column B to generate a holistic picture of the In short, I like to see if the numbers accord with my perception of how the team looks. Ideally, each game Georgia plays gives us more information and more quantifiable data to shape a narrative.
After the Oklahoma game, though, I feel like I know less about this team than I did the week before.
Or at least I did until I rewatched the game a few days ago and realized the problem: This game was narratively backwards. In my season preview on the Sooners, I predicted a back-and-forth, defensive struggle in the first half before UGA pulled away to put the Sooners to bed. And if you showed me only the quarterback stats from the game (Mateer went 25/34 for 231 yards, two touchdowns and a pick to Gunner Stockton’s 171 yards on 14/25 for one score and one pick), I would’ve assumed that’s what happened.
Instead, Georgia came out of the gate foaming at the mouth. After a three-and-out on the first drive, the Dawgs scored on their next two possessions, driving for 79 and 54 yards, respectively. Add in Chris Cole’s defensive score and another touchdown off Mateer’s second fumble of the day, and the rout appeared to be on.
Until it wasn’t. Credit to Brent Venables, I don’t know what kind of locker room speech you give down 28-0 after watching your quarterback play the worst half of football of his career, but the Sooners came out of the locker room ready to play. Instead of rolling over, the Oklahoma defense stood up. After giving up 21 points in the first half (the scoop and score wasn’t on the defense), they held Georgia to 13 in the second, basically playing UGA to a draw. After racking up 103 yards in the first half, Stockton only tallied 68 in the second half of the game. He also had a pick on an ill-advised throw that didn’t have quite enough zip to get to Lawson Luckie.
Flip the halves, and you have a much more compelling story. The game would feel totally different, a story about Stockton and the offense growing into the game, hanging tough, and eventually overpowering a stout defense. Instead, it felt like the team went into a shell over the last 30 minutes and ran out of gas. Somewhat oddly, this second-half turtling wasn’t the result of running out the clock and trying to salt away the lead; of Georgia’s 53 offensive snaps, 27 were passes to 26 runs.
I tend to think of Georgia as a second-half team, and a point of pride for the program has been its superior athleticism and conditioning. To beat Georgia, you have to win all four quarters. Seeing an already-defeated opponent keep trying to battle back as the offense sputters, especially if it’s not in shorten-the-game mode, leaves a sour taste.
Another of the continuing narratives about Georgia is some sense of offensive dysfunction. The media tends to discuss the Dawgs as a terrifying hydra on defense wedded to a just-okay, ball-control offense, usually helmed by a competent but unspectacular quarterback. Kirby Smart’s Georgia teams are just never going to have an aggressive, vertical, “Talyn/London/Isiah is down there somewhere!” passing attack. But Stockton can make big-time throws: Just look at the long touchdown pass to Talyn Taylor for evidence. It was a perfectly designed play where Taylor ran his route perfectly, the protection held up, and Stockton ripped an absolute dime to him. We have that club in the bag. How often we’ll need to use it remains to be seen, I suppose.
Along those same lines, there’s plenty to like about what we saw last Saturday. Even without the two scores off turnovers, Georgia still would’ve won comfortably. Against a fearsome rush, the offensive line held up well in pass protection and gave up only one sack on the day. The rushing total is a little underwhelming — 129 yards on the ground — but some of that is the absence of Frazier. And Stockton did have his worst game of the year by far, although it would be hard not to take a step back after his stellar opening to the season. Plus, this is very likely the best defense the Dawgs will play all year, and we controlled the line of scrimmage well. The Arkansan weirdness aside, the o-line’s performance has been the brightest spot of the year for me.
If UGA plays a game like the first half of this one, there are very, very few teams in the conference or the country who can beat them. But the Sooners are a half-team with a broken offense. I’m not going to be overly critical of Mateer (the Oklahoma subreddit can do it for me), but I think it’s clear he’s hit his ceiling. On the whoopsie-daisy fumble that Cole returned, he had a man open for a touchdown and lost the ball because he inexplicably decided to pump fake. Generally, he appeared to have the confidence of a man who’s realizing that the episode of Maury he’s on is gonna involve a paternity test.
Still, part of what takes a defense from good to great is the ability to capitalize on your opponent’s mistakes, and this year’s defense looks much more like the vintage UGA soul-eaters than the 2025 edition did. GlimmerTwin rightly noted that Mateer managed to escape more than you’d like him to, but overall, the Dawgs controlled both lines of scrimmage and were getting good pressure that obviously rattled the opposing quarterback.
The Oklahoma game is a good test of your optimism. It’s like the football equivalent of Radiohead’s “Lucky,” a song about surviving an airplane crash that muses on whether such an event would be lucky (because you lived) or unlucky (because you were in an airplane that crashed). If you can beat Oklahoma, even the scratch ‘n’ dent version of 2026, by playing a half-great game, you might be pretty good. Or you might just be lucky.
And now it’s Vandy time. I attended Vanderbilt as an undergraduate, which meant I wasn’t a football fan. Things were so bleak that, when Vandy beat Kentucky to snap a 23-game SEC losing streak my freshman year, the students ripped out the goal post and paraded it down West End Avenue. Imagine being so bereft that beating Kentucky is worth celebrating. Then again, Texas A&M couldn’t do it, so maybe it is worth three cheers. But most weekends, you’d barely notice if there was a game going on.
Anyway, for most of the school’s history, a game against Vanderbilt was a voucher the other conference teams got to cash in for an SEC win. Now, fresh off the most successful season in school history and poaching a five-star quarterback from *ahem* another SEC school, the ’Dores are feeling themselves a bit. They’re coming into Athens for the first time since 2022 (and for the first meeting between the teams since 2023) with the belief that they can win this game.
A motivated opponent, an early kick, and some emerging bad blood between the programs: We’ve got the makings of a trap game here. That was more or less the recipe that led to the last Georgia loss to an unranked opponent in the 2019 South Carolina game.
There is a path to victory for Vandy, I suppose, if Jared Curtis plays out of his mind because he has a chip on his shoulder. They would also probably need some turnover luck. And Vegas has UGA as more than a three-score favorite, so if everything goes according to plan, we should spend a chunk of the second half getting the backups some valuable experience.
This team has looked focused in all its games, coming out sharp instead of playing around before waking up. But it hasn’t yet been truly tested, nor has it played a complete game yet. Based on the flashes we’ve seen so far, I think this could be as terrifying a monster as the ’21-’22 teams. I doubt this will be that week, but that’s why they play the games.
More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos