Austin Mack’s Response to Alabama’s QB Decision Shows Exactly Why the Crimson Tide Still Needs Him

NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...

There are a lot of ways a quarterback can respond when he finds out he is not going to be the starter.

He can pout.

He can pull away from his teammates.

He can start thinking about the transfer portal.

He can mentally check out.

Or he can do what Austin Mack has apparently done.

He can show back up to work.

And in my opinion, the way Mack has handled being named Alabama’s second-string quarterback says everything you need to know about the kind of player, and person, Alabama has in that quarterback room.

Kalen DeBoer made the decision to go with Keelon Russell as Alabama’s starting quarterback, and I have already said that I believe it was the right decision. Russell earned the opportunity, and Alabama’s coaching staff clearly believes he gives the Crimson Tide the best chance to win.

But that does not mean Austin Mack failed. It does not mean Mack suddenly became a bad quarterback. And it certainly does not mean Alabama does not need him.

Actually, I think the opposite may be true.

The way Mack has responded to the disappointment of not winning the starting job may make him even more valuable to this Alabama football team.

DeBoer spoke about Mack’s response after the quarterback decision and shared something that really stood out to me.

Mack’s car was reportedly one of the first, if not the first, back at the facility the very next day after finding out Keelon was named QB1.

Think about that for a second. This is a quarterback who had spent months competing for the job. He transferred to Alabama with a relationship already established with DeBoer. He knew the system. He had experience in the offense. He had put in the work. He had waited for his opportunity. And then he was told that the job belonged to somebody else.

Nobody would have blamed him for being disappointed. Nobody would have blamed him for needing a day to process it. He is human.

That is exactly what DeBoer acknowledged when talking about him. Mack invested a tremendous amount of himself into this competition. Of course losing out on the starting job hurt.

But what matters is what he did next. He went back to work.

That tells me more about Austin Mack than almost anything else could.

It is easy to talk about being a team player when everything is going your way. It is easy to say all the right things when you are QB1. It is easy to smile when your name is the one being announced as the starter.

Character shows up when things do not go your way.

Mack could have allowed disappointment to become bitterness.

Instead, he apparently chose preparation. That matters. And Alabama fans should appreciate it.

DeBoer has continued to make it clear that he thinks extremely highly of Mack as a quarterback. He essentially said that Mack did not lose anything through this competition. He did not fail.

I think that distinction is incredibly important. Sometimes there is this assumption in quarterback competitions that one quarterback “won” because the other quarterback must have done something wrong. That is not always how it works.

Sometimes two players can both be really good quarterbacks, and the coaching staff simply believes one gives them a slightly better option at that particular moment.

That appears to be what happened at Alabama.

Keelon Russell won the job. Austin Mack did not lose his ability. Those two things can be true at the same time. And Alabama may be incredibly thankful for that at some point this season.

We have watched enough college football to know how quickly everything can change.

One play. One injury. One helmet coming off. One bad hit. One situation where the backup quarterback suddenly hears his name called and has approximately five seconds to stop being the backup quarterback. That is why DeBoer’s comments about Mack being ready when his number is called were so important.

Maybe Russell’s helmet comes off and Mack has to enter on third or fourth down. Maybe Alabama is backed up against its own goal line. Maybe it is the fourth quarter of a rivalry game. Maybe the season is hanging in the balance. Nobody knows.

But the backup quarterback cannot spend the week feeling sorry for himself. He has to prepare like he is going to play every snap while knowing there is a chance he will not play at all.

That is one of the hardest jobs in football.

And based on everything we are hearing, Mack is handling it exactly the way Alabama needs him to.

There is another part of this story that I think deserves attention, too. Mack is not only continuing to work inside Alabama’s quarterback room. He is still representing the program outside of it.

After practice Thursday, Mack reached out to 2028 Alabama quarterback commit Charles Scott Jr. via social media and wished him luck ahead of his high school season opener.

That may sound like a small thing. I do not think it is.

Put yourself in Mack’s position. You just lost the starting quarterback competition. You could understandably be focused entirely on yourself. Your future. Your playing time. Your career.

Instead, Mack is still investing in another quarterback who will not even arrive at Alabama for quite some time.

That is leadership. And that is exactly the kind of player you want inside your program.

Mack easily could have decided, “Well, if I’m not starting, this is not my responsibility anymore.”

He didn’t. He is still recruiting.

Still encouraging. Still working. Still representing Alabama. That is impressive.

And honestly, it makes me root for him even more.

There is such an immediate-gratification mentality in college football right now. If a player does not start, people immediately ask whether he is transferring. If someone loses a position battle, we automatically begin discussing his next destination. Sometimes transferring is absolutely the right decision for a player, and there is nothing wrong with that. But there is also something incredibly admirable about a player who responds to adversity by saying, in effect, “Okay. I’m going back to work.”

That reminds me a little bit of what Alabama fans watched with Jalen Hurts.

No, the situations are not identical. They do not have to be identical for the lesson to apply.

Hurts went from being Alabama’s starting quarterback and SEC Offensive Player of the Year to watching Tua Tagovailoa become the starter.

He could have left immediately. He stayed. He worked. He supported Tua. He prepared. And then Alabama needed him.

When Tagovailoa was injured in the 2018 SEC Championship Game against Georgia, Hurts stepped onto the field and delivered one of the most memorable moments of his Alabama career. That game became a reminder of why the backup quarterback matters.

You never know when your opportunity is coming. Austin Mack may not know either. But the key is being ready if it does.

That is why Mack showing up immediately after losing the starting job matters. The work he puts in now may become the reason Alabama wins a football game later. And there is another side of this that I think is important.

Mack’s response probably helps Keelon Russell, too.

Imagine how much different this quarterback room could feel if Mack had reacted poorly. Imagine a veteran quarterback pulling away from the starter. Imagine tension in meetings. Imagine two groups forming inside the locker room. Imagine one quarterback secretly waiting for the other one to struggle.

That can poison a football team.

Instead, Alabama appears to have a quarterback room where the competition was real, the decision was made, and now everybody has a job to do.

That is exactly how a championship-level program has to operate. Russell needs Mack.

He needs somebody in that room who understands the offense. He needs somebody who can see things from the sideline. He needs somebody who can tell him what he noticed from the defense. He needs somebody who is competing with him while still supporting him. And Mack can provide all of that.

Being the backup quarterback does not mean you stop leading. Sometimes it actually requires more leadership. Anybody can lead when the spotlight is shining on them. It takes a different level of maturity to lead when somebody else is standing in the spotlight.

That is what makes Mack’s response so impressive. And I also want Alabama fans to remember something as this season begins: Do not treat Austin Mack like some quarterback Alabama has sitting around because he was not good enough to start.

That is not the situation. Mack is talented. Very talented.

He has been in DeBoer’s system for years. He understands the offense. He has the physical tools. He has the size. He has the arm talent. Most importantly, his head coach clearly believes in him.

DeBoer did not talk about Mack like a quarterback who disappointed him. He talked about him like a quarterback he still trusts.

There is a huge difference.

Mack did not fail. Russell simply earned the job. Now Mack has another role to embrace. And based on everything we have seen so far, he is embracing it.

That should make Alabama fans feel incredibly good about the quarterback position heading into this season. Obviously, everyone hopes Russell stays healthy and plays well enough that there is never a quarterback controversy. But Alabama also has the luxury of knowing that if something happens, its backup is not somebody who mentally checked out after losing the competition.

He is preparing. He is working. He is staying involved with recruiting. He is still representing the University of Alabama. And he is waiting for his opportunity.

Maybe that opportunity comes this year. Maybe it comes later. Maybe it comes in a way none of us can predict right now. But football has a funny way of rewarding players who stay ready. That is why I would tell Austin Mack the same thing I would tell any player who finds himself disappointed after a position battle:

Keep working. Your story is not over. Being QB2 in August does not define your career. And sometimes the moments people remember forever come after the disappointment nobody thought you could overcome.

Austin Mack wanted to be Alabama’s starting quarterback. Of course he did. He should have wanted that. And losing that competition probably hurt more than any of us on the outside can understand.

But he showed up the next day anyway. That is the part I keep coming back to.

He showed up. Not weeks later. Not after sulking. Not after making the situation about himself. He showed up and went back to work.

That is Alabama football.

That is what competition is supposed to look like.

You fight like crazy to win the job. When the decision is made, you continue fighting for the team.

Keelon Russell may be Alabama’s QB1. But Austin Mack still matters. A lot.

He matters in that quarterback room. He matters on the practice field. He matters to Russell’s development. He matters as a leader. He matters as an ambassador for the program.

And there may eventually come a moment when Alabama needs No. 2 on the depth chart to play like a No. 1.

If that moment comes, I have a feeling Austin Mack will be ready. Because everything we have seen since the quarterback decision tells us exactly who he is.

He is disappointed, I’m sure. But he is not defeated.

He did not win the starting job. But he did not quit working.

And sometimes how a player handles not getting what he wanted tells you more about him than winning ever could.

Roll Tide. 

More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos