Don’t sleep on Earl Little Jr. and his All-American potential at Ohio State

NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...

Ohio State did not bring Earl Little Jr. to Columbus simply to replace a name on the depth chart. The Buckeyes brought him in because they believe he can become one of the most important pieces in the next version of their defense.

The departure of Caleb Downs, along with several other defensive stars from Ohio State’s historic 2025 unit, created obvious questions about how the Buckeyes would rebuild the secondary.

Little was an obvious answer, but perhaps not in the way everyone initially expected. After playing primarily as a free safety at Florida State, he has increasingly looked like the ideal solution at Ohio State’s nickel position, giving Matt Patricia a veteran defensive back who can move around the formation and create problems from multiple alignments.

The early returns have been difficult to ignore. Little was one of the most frequently praised players throughout Ohio State’s spring, with observers noting his physicality, communication and ability to contribute in coverage while also attacking the line of scrimmage.

Ryan Day and the staff has identified him as one of the spring’s biggest standouts, while players and coaches alike have emphasized his communication and leadership in a secondary undergoing significant turnover.

That is why the conversation around Little should be bigger than simply asking whether he can replace what Ohio State lost. The more interesting question is how good he can actually be.

There is a legitimate path for Little to go from a second-team All-ACC safety in 2025 to a first-team All-Big Ten defender and legitimate All-American candidate in 2026.

The resume is already there. The role could make it even better

Little’s path to Ohio State is an interesting one because his talent was never really in question. He arrived at Alabama as one of the nation’s premier defensive back recruits in the 2022 class.

A unanimous four-star prospect, Little was ranked as high as No. 38 nationally by On3 and was a top-15 cornerback nationally in multiple major recruiting services. He was coached by Patrick Surtain Sr. at American Heritage in Fort Lauderdale and selected Alabama over Florida State, Miami, LSU and more than 30 other offers.

The Crimson Tide did not immediately turn him into a star, however. After limited opportunities in Tuscaloosa, Little transferred to Florida State and eventually found the role that unlocked his game.

As a first-year starter at safety, Little led Florida State with 76 tackles, adding four interceptions, two forced fumbles, two tackles for loss and two pass breakups.

His four interceptions ranked fourth in the ACC and 16th nationally, and he became the first Seminole since 2016 to intercept a pass in three consecutive games. That performance earned him second-team All-ACC honors on the season.

His coverage numbers help explain why Ohio State was so interested. According to Pro Football Focus data, Little was targeted 22 times across 342 coverage snaps and allowed only 14 catches for 168 yards and two touchdowns. That is a fascinating foundation for a nickel defender.

Little is not simply a safety who can survive closer to the line of scrimmage. He has already demonstrated that he can operate in space, play deep, diagnose passing concepts and make plays on the football.

At roughly 6 feet and 198 pounds, he also has enough size and physicality to become a legitimate presence against the run and bigger slot targets.

And that physicality has already been one of the defining themes surrounding him in Columbus. Devin Sanchez described Little as someone who “sets the tone,” noting his willingness to come downhill, strike running backs and immediately communicate with the rest of the secondary.

That combination is precisely what makes the nickel role so valuable. They have to cover receivers, carry routes downfield, match tight ends, fit against the run, blitz, communicate rotations and diagnose formations without knowing exactly where they will be asked to align after the snap.

Little can do all of those things. And that gives Patricia something he simply cannot manufacture through scheme alone. A defensive back who allows the scheme to remain unpredictable.

This is where Little can become different from the Buckeyes’ recent defensive backs

Ohio State has had exceptional safeties and defensive backs in recent years, but Little brings a slightly different profile.

Downs was extraordinary because he could seemingly do everything. Sonny Styles brought size and violence near the line of scrimmage. Lathan Ransom combined physicality and versatility. Jordan Fuller was an elite communicator and organizer.

Little’s game is different. He has the instincts and ball skills of a safety, but the mentality of a nickel defender or even linebacker. That distinction could become extremely valuable for Patricia.

The defensive coordinator does not need Little to sit at one depth and wait for the quarterback to make a mistake. He can move him around. He can align him over the slot, rotate him into the box, disguise two-high structures, blitz him, match tight ends and still trust him to retreat into coverage.

That creates uncertainty for quarterbacks, and uncertainty creates opportunities for the rest of Ohio State’s defense.

Picture it, Kenyatta Jackson Jr., Qua Russaw, Beau Atkinson and Zion Grady coming off the edge. Eddrick Houston, James Smith, John Walker and Will Smith Jr. controlling the interior. Payton Pierce and Christian Alliegro developing into bigger factors at linebacker, and a secondary rounded out by Devin Sanchez, Jermaine Mathews Jr., Jaylen McClain, Terry Moore and Little.

The best version of Little’s role isn’t simply about how many tackles or interceptions he produces. It is about how many things Ohio State can ask him to do without changing personnel.

That is the real value of a modern chess piece. And it is why Little’s potential production could be much higher than his 2025 numbers suggest.

He doesn’t necessarily need 76 tackles again. In fact, a significant decline in tackles could be a positive sign if it means Ohio State’s front seven is doing more of the work.

What would matter more is whether Little can combine his coverage efficiency with increased disruption. Several interceptions, consistent pass breakups, tackles for loss, forced turnovers and the kind of third-down plays that change possessions.

If he gets to something like 60-plus tackles, three to five interceptions, multiple tackles for loss and a handful of forced turnovers while becoming one of Ohio State’s most trusted coverage defenders, the awards conversation becomes very real.

The ceiling is much higher than second/third team All-Big Ten

There is already evidence that national evaluators see Little as one of the conference’s best defensive backs. Phil Steele placed him on his first-team Preseason All-Big Ten team and also named him a fourth-team Preseason All-American.

Athlon was slightly more conservative, putting Little on its second-team All-Big Ten team. Those aren’t predictions that he will necessarily reach those heights, but they demonstrate the baseline expectations surrounding him entering his first season in Columbus.

And frankly, the Athlon and Phil Steele distinctions may ultimately undersell his eventual ceiling. If Little is merely good in 2026, second-team All-Big Ten is probably where the conversation ends.

But if he is the player Ohio State believes he can be, the conversation changes. First-team All-Big Ten becomes the expectation. All-American becomes realistic. And if the Buckeyes’ defense is again among the nation’s best while Little becomes the communicator and matchup weapon at the heart of it, he could even enter the discussion for the conference’s top defensive player.

That is not as outrageous as it sounds. Little already received second-team All-ACC recognition after his first full season as a starter. He is now entering his second season in that role, moving into a defensive system specifically capable of maximizing his versatility, surrounded by considerably more talent than he had at Florida State.

The jump from 2025 to 2026 does not require him to become a fundamentally different player. It requires him to become a more complete version of the player who already exists.

That is perhaps the most exciting part. The question isn’t whether Little has the athleticism, cause he does. It isn’t whether he can cover, cause his 2025 numbers suggest he can. It isn’t whether he can tackle, his production and spring reputation answer that. It isn’t even whether he can make plays on the football, four interceptions last season provide plenty of evidence.

The question is whether all of those skills can come together consistently enough for him to become one of the defining players on an Ohio State defense. And that is where 2026 gets really interesting for the Florida native.

Ohio State needs Earl Little Jr. to become exactly this player

There is a temptation to view Little as another transfer who has been brought in to fill a vacancy, but that undersells the move.

Ohio State did not simply need another defensive back after losing Downs, Davison Igbinosun and Lorenzo Styles Jr. They needed players capable of giving Patricia the flexibility to build another elite defense without having to recreate last year’s personnel exactly.

Little might be the most important part of that solution. He gives the Buckeyes experience. He gives them physicality. He gives them coverage ability. He gives them communication. And, perhaps most importantly, he gives them versatility.

Those qualities have already made him one of the most talked-about players around the Woody Hayes Athletic Center this offseason. Now comes the part that matters, production.

If Little can turn this spring momentum into the kind of fall season his talent suggests is possible, Ohio State may have much more than a reliable nickel defender. They may have one of the best defensive backs in the country.

The safest prediction is that Little will be an All-Big Ten caliber player. The more aggressive prediction is that he becomes a first-team All-Big Ten selection and one of the most disruptive hybrid defenders in the conference. But the ceiling is even higher.

If everything clicks, if Patricia’s defense allows him to play fast, if the secondary develops around him and if Little continues making plays on the ball while becoming one of Ohio State’s most reliable downhill defenders, an All-American season is absolutely within reach.

That would make Earl Little Jr. much more than a replacement for what Ohio State lost. It would make him one of the players who defines what the next great Buckeye defense becomes.

More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos