ESPN's College GameDay Accused Of Influencing Firing Decisions

NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...

For decades ESPN's College GameDay has been about as important of a part of the college football viewing experience as the opening kickoff itself. But there seems to be a sense out there that the show is actively harming some coaches' job prospects.

In a new poll of anonymous coaches done by The Athletic, one assistant from an SEC school asserted that GameDay is playing a role in who gets hired and fired. The assistant asserted that when the analysts on the show like Kirk Herbstreit declare that a specific coach is doing a good or bad job, the people in charge at those schools believe it and act accordingly.

"Whatever is said on 'GameDay' is like gold because now more than ever the fan support matters more than anything else. The fan support is paying the bills. It always has, but even more so now. You’ve got to keep those guys happy and they get their information from those guys on 'College GameDay.' If Kirk Herbstreit said some guy is doing a really good job, they’re going to believe it. If they say he’s not doing a good job, they’re going to believe it. Right, wrong or indifferent, whatever is said they’re going to believe it," the coach said.

Anonymous SEC coach says ‘College GameDay’ influences hiring/firing decisions https://t.co/SLYZGGuMrDpic.twitter.com/2sbhqHOA4p

— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) March 10, 2026

Another argued that the influence is more indirect, with strong opinions influencing donors and by extension the athletic department's pocketbook.

The poll found that four of six coaches that were asked about it all agreed that athletic directors are influenced by GameDay in hiring and firing.

Cause or Effect?

2025 certainly seemed to showcase GameDay doing some PR work for certain coaches. Many of the analysts on the show played defense for Lane Kiffin before and even during the drama between him and Ole Miss up until the ink was dry on his controversial move to LSU.

But the easy counter to that is that College GameDay simply points out what just about anyone who watches the game can see. The results show on the field with some coaches thriving and others clearly struggling.

It's not like coaches didn't have notoriously short leashes for generations prior to 2025 either. The only real difference is that schools have way more money and are thus more willing to throw it away if they don't see early returns on investment from the football people.

Do you think College GameDay has an unfair influence on coaching?

This story was originally published by The Spun on Mar 10, 2026, where it first appeared in the College Football section. Add The Spun as a Preferred Source by clicking here.

More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos