Should Oklahoma Fire Ben Arbuckle and Promote Kevin Wilson?

NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...

It is not time to fire Ben Arbuckle.

One ugly road loss at Michigan does not justify blowing up the offense in mid-September. It is time, though, to talk about the backup plan if this thing never gets fixed.

And if Oklahoma needs a midseason stabilizer, the best option is already on staff: Kevin Wilson.

That is not a panic take. That is a roster-of-coaches reality. Oklahoma’s offense looked stuck in Ann Arbor. The line failed to create consistent push, the run game bottomed out at 3.4 yards per carry, John Mateer missed too many throws, and Isaiah Sategna basically disappeared.

Arbuckle has to own part of that. So does the quarterback. So does the offensive line. And yes, so does Brent Venables.

That last part matters because this keeps happening in Norman. Venables has now had four primary offensive coordinator or co-offensive coordinator setups in his tenure: Jeff Lebby, Seth Littrell, Joe Jon Finley, and Ben Arbuckle. Lebby is the only one who left for a clear promotion, taking the head job at Mississippi State. The rest of the pattern is harder to ignore.

Good offensive minds come in with reputations and then the operation starts looking constrained, conservative, or just plain out of rhythm. At some point you have to ask how much of the offense is being held back by the head coach’s comfort level, the defensive identity driving the whole program, or both.

That does not make Arbuckle blameless. The Michigan film was bad. If Oklahoma spends another month protecting soft, missing open receivers, and living behind the chains, the conversation changes from patience to urgency. In that scenario, Wilson is the cleanest internal answer available.

People forget how good Wilson was in Norman because enough time has passed for it to feel like ancient history.

It should not.

As co-offensive coordinator from 2002 to 2005 and offensive coordinator from 2006 to 2010, Wilson helped build the most explosive stretch of Oklahoma football in the Stoops era. The Sooners won six Big 12 titles and played for national championships after the 2003, 2004, and 2008 seasons. The 2008 team scored 716 points in 14 games, averaged 51.1 points per night, and became the first program in college football history to hang 60 or more points in five consecutive games. Wilson won the Broyles Award that year as the nation’s top assistant. He also helped maximize Jason White and Sam Bradford into Heisman winners by marrying tempo, explosive pass designs, and a run game that still forced defenses to account for leverage and speed.

That is not some random analyst with a clipboard and a good memory. That is one of the best offensive coaches in program history, now sitting in the building as assistant head coach for offense after stops as Indiana’s head coach, Tulsa’s head coach, and Ohio State’s offensive coordinator.

Would a midseason switch fix everything? No. Nobody should sell that fantasy.

Offensive line play does not magically improve because the headset changes hands. Mateer’s accuracy does not reset overnight. The bigger question is whether Venables would actually loosen the reins enough for Wilson to be Wilson. That is the real concern. If Oklahoma makes a change and then still forces the offense to play tight, safe, and reactive, the staff move becomes cosmetics.

But if the Sooners need a short-term answer, Wilson is the strongest one they could make without ripping the whole operation apart. He knows the program. He knows what championship-level offense is supposed to look like in Norman. He has installed systems on short timelines before. And he gives Venables a way to change the temperature without going outside the building in October.

Again, it is not time to pull that lever yet. Arbuckle deserves the chance to correct the Michigan tape, especially with New Mexico up next and a full slate of answers still available in-house. The run game can get better. The protection can settle. Mateer can throw more decisively. The tight ends can stay involved. All of that is still on the table.

What Oklahoma should not do is pretend there is no contingency. The fan base can already feel the offense tightening. The Michigan loss made it worse. If this unit stays stuck, Venables is going to need more than another week of the same answers. He may need a different voice calling the game.

In that moment, Kevin Wilson is not a miracle cure. He is the best available reset button Oklahoma has.

More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos