The North Was Lying: College Football’s Hidden Jim Crow System

NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...

Northern schools spent 80 years congratulating themselves for letting black players on the field — and quietly benching them whenever the South came to town.

On November 18, 1892, the University of Missouri forfeited a football game rather than play it. No team had ever done that before. Nebraska had a halfback named George Flippin, and Missouri decided losing was preferable to sharing a field with him.

Nebraska’s student newspaper had a good time with it — joked that Missouri’s objection amounted to the Civil War fought over again in miniature. It’s a funny line. It also aged terribly. Within 25 years, Nebraska had banned black athletes from its own rosters entirely, and that ban held until after World War II. The school that laughed at Missouri’s bigotry in 1892 spent the next several decades quietly practicing its own version.

The story Americans know about football and segregation is a southern one. Bear Bryant. George Wallace. The SEC dragging its feet into the 1970s. All of it true. But the northern schools doing the moralizing ran their own color line for eighty years — not in statute, where somebody could have repealed it, but in phone calls between coaches.

A school let one man in, took credit for it, and shut the door behind him. Nobody ever wrote the rule down, so nobody ever had to answer for it.

The First

The first black players at a predominantly white college played for Amherst, a small liberal arts school in western Massachusetts. William Tecumseh Sherman Jackson and William Henry Lewis arrived in the fall of 1888 from the Virginia Normal and Collegiate Institute in Petersburg, a school for black students. Neither had played organized football. Gym class at Virginia Normal had meant marching laps around the building.

Amherst treated athletics as something close to a moral obligation, so Lewis took up the sport mostly because the school told him to. He showed up to his first practice in street clothes. “That first day I got my clothes all torn off and my feet stepped on,” he said later. “The next day they gave me a uniform.”

Jackson took the field first, in 1889 — the earliest confirmed black player on a predominantly white college roster in the country. But it’s Lewis whose story carries. He became Amherst’s captain, the first black captain of a predominantly white college team anywhere. He went to Harvard Law, played two more seasons at center, and became the first black player named to college football’s All-America team — twice.

Football turned out to be the least interesting thing about him. Taft appointed him Assistant U.S. Attorney General in 1911, the first black man to hold the office, and he was among the first black attorneys admitted to the American Bar Association. Jackson’s path was quieter: teaching, then a high school principalship in Washington. Which is a large part of why Lewis is the name that got remembered.

A year after Jackson’s debut, a Michigan student named George Jewett became the first black letterman in that school’s history, then transferred to Northwestern and became the first there too. Michigan did not have another black football player for 42 years — not until Willis Ward in 1932.

What It Cost

Flippin was the son of a formerly enslaved man who fought for the Union and became a doctor. He arrived in Lincoln in 1891 as roughly the fifth black athlete competing at any predominantly white university in the country. He was enormous for the era — 6-foot-2, 200 pounds — and by a wide margin the best all-around athlete on campus, setting school records in the shot put and hammer throw and winning wrestling championships on the side.

He was refused entry to a Denver opera house after a road game. A restaurant in Omaha seated his entire team in a private back room so other diners wouldn’t have to look at him. When a hotel refused him a room, his teammates walked out with him until the hotel caved — then set up a segregated eating area so other guests wouldn’t know he was staying there.

The Missouri forfeit changed the rulebook. Embarrassed by the walkout, the brand-new conference the two schools belonged to passed a rule the following season: any team forfeiting a scheduled game would be fined $50. Missouri paid it once, then folded, playing Nebraska and Flippin in both 1893 and 1894.

In 1894 his teammates elected him captain. Nebraska’s own coach wouldn’t let it stand. A black man wasn’t going to captain the team, whatever the vote said.

When Flippin died in 1929 — by then a small-town doctor who had built the first hospital in Stromsburg, Nebraska — local sportswriters eulogized him like a legend. One compared him to a charging bull bred with a tiger’s ferocity. What the obituaries left out: the next black player to wear a Nebraska uniform, a lineman named Clinton Ross, lasted three seasons before Kansas State’s coach threatened to boycott a 1913 game rather than face him. Nebraska played anyway. Then nobody suited up for the Huskers again until 1952. Thirty-nine years.

The Gentlemen’s Agreement

The arrangement had a name.

By the early 20th century college football had gone national, and northern and southern schools started scheduling each other. Northern programs had integrated modestly, one or two players at a time. Southern programs hadn’t, and under Jim Crow legally couldn’t. So when the two sides agreed to play, an unwritten understanding took hold: whatever black player the northern team had would sit that game out.

No governing body enforced it. No rule was written anywhere. It was handled coach to coach, and everyone involved called it gentlemanly.

It happened constantly, and not at obscure programs. In the 1930s alone it’s documented at least 21 separate times — Michigan, Ohio State, Michigan State, Minnesota, Indiana, Iowa, plus a string of Ivy League schools. Fitzhugh Lyons and Jesse Babb sat when Mississippi State came to Bloomington, on Indiana’s own field. Iowa benched two black players against George Washington; the coach told reporters he’d asked them to sit “for the good of the sport.” The Naval Academy refused outright to play Ohio State’s Bill Bell, but had no objection to a light-skinned Cuban player on NYU’s roster that same season. The color line ran on some very selective eyesight.

The clearest case came in 1934. Georgia Tech told Michigan they’d play the scheduled game in Ann Arbor — on Michigan’s own campus — only if Michigan benched its star end, Willis Ward. Michigan agreed. Georgia Tech reciprocated by benching its own star so neither team would look like it had won anything unfair. Both squads took the field a man short, in a game that existed only because a black man wasn’t allowed to be in it.

Students didn’t take it quietly. A group calling itself the Ward United Front Committee collected 1,500 signatures demanding Ward play or the game be canceled. The campus held what one newspaper called the wildest and strangest Friday night rally in Michigan’s history. None of it changed anything. Ward wasn’t even allowed to watch from his own team’s bench.

Athletic director Fielding Yost took rumors of a field protest seriously enough to hire the Pinkerton Detective Agency to investigate his own students. Two agents spent a day on campus and reported back a list of ringleaders. There was no protest being planned. Yost had paid strangers to spy on undergraduates over nothing.

Ward’s roommate and closest friend on the team, a lineman named Gerald Ford, threatened to quit in protest. Ward talked him out of it — told him the team needed him. Ford played. Three decades later, as a member of Congress, he voted for the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act, and said he never forgot that Saturday.

Not every southern coach played along. In 1937 Southern Methodist took the field against UCLA and its two black stars, Kenny Washington and Woody Strode, without benching anybody. SMU’s coach, Matty Bell, had played pro football alongside black teammates and said flatly that he thought every boy should get his chance regardless of color. No boycott followed. No forfeit. The agreement was never as airtight or unanimous as the schools that kept honoring it liked to claim.

Cracks

The system started breaking in 1940 at NYU. The school had a black player named Leonard Bates, and when NYU scheduled Missouri, the agreement kicked in automatically. Bates was benched. This time students picketed with signs reading “Bates Must Play” and “End Jim Crow in Sports,” and demanded NYU stop scheduling segregated opponents on those terms. It didn’t change that game. But for the first time the arrangement had to be defended out loud instead of handled behind closed doors.

World War II accelerated things. Men who had fought — in many cases alongside black soldiers, in a still-segregated military — came home with a lot less patience for the idea that a teammate needed permission to play. Rosters filled with G.I. Bill veterans, and some of them started threatening to boycott their own trips south if a black teammate was left behind. That pressure, coming from inside the locker room, did more to erode the arrangement than a decade of protest had managed.

The clearest early proof came in January 1948, when Penn State reached the Cotton Bowl in Dallas with two black players, Wally Triplett and Dennie Hoggard. Matty Bell — the same SMU coach who had taken the field against Washington and Strode — pushed Cotton Bowl officials to extend the invitation anyway. “We have no objections ourselves,” he told the Dallas Morning News.

Word still reached the Penn State locker room that somebody wanted to meet and hash the matter out. Team captain Steve Suhey shut it down before it started: We are Penn State. There will be no meetings.

No hotel in Dallas would house the team, so Penn State bunked at a nearby naval base. Triplett caught the tying touchdown in a 13-13 game against Doak Walker’s SMU squad — the first black player to score a touchdown in a major college game inside a former Confederate state.

By the 1950s the old arrangement was falling apart, though not gone. As late as January 1956, the Sugar Bowl in New Orleans hadn’t seen a single black player in 20 years of existence, and Georgia’s governor tried to force Georgia Tech to pull out rather than face a Pittsburgh team with a black player named Bobby Grier. Georgia Tech’s president refused. The game was played, and Grier became the first black player to appear in a bowl game in the Deep South — 64 years after Flippin first took the field for Nebraska.

The Ceiling

By the early 1960s the formal arrangement was mostly dead in the North. What it left behind was almost as effective: an unwritten ceiling.

Charles H. Martin, whose book Benching Jim Crowremains the definitive study of the era, found dozens of northern universities that excluded black players from their own rosters entirely well into the 1940s — with no southern opponent or scheduled game involved at all. And the programs that opened up rarely opened up far. USC sat in one of the most diverse cities in America and carried five black players on its 1962 national championship team, seven on its 1967 championship team — one of them O.J. Simpson.

Nobody at USC ever announced a quota. Nobody had to. The roster counted itself. A genuinely integrated team, deep at every position, was still close to unthinkable at the top of the sport.

Duffy Daugherty And The Underground Raiload

Duffy Daugherty didn’t look like a revolutionary. Short, stocky, the son of Scottish immigrants out of a Pennsylvania coal town, known mostly for corny jokes and a soft spot for his players. He took over at Michigan State in 1954, inheriting a program already recruiting a modest number of black players under his predecessor, Biggie Munn.

What Daugherty did, starting around 1959, was refuse to stop at the number everyone else quietly agreed was the limit.

The system that made it possible started with black high school coaches across the segregated South — not with Daugherty. Their best players were barred from the flagship universities in their own home states, so those coaches started calling Michigan State directly. We’ve got a kid who could start anywhere in the country and there’s no path for him here. Will you take him?

The first to make the trip was Clifton Roaf, out of Pine Bluff, Arkansas, in 1959. That same year a halfback named Sherman Lewis came up from Louisville, and by 1963 he finished third in the Heisman voting. Three years later a linebacker out of Roanoke, Virginia, named Charlie Thornhill got a look because a white sportswriter back home made an unsolicited call to the staff, simply because he thought the kid deserved a shot. Roaf, by then a senior, hosted Thornhill’s recruiting visit himself.

That’s how the pipeline actually worked. One relationship at a time, built by people with no formal connection to the program who decided the talent shouldn’t go to waste. Michigan State’s own players eventually gave it a name borrowed from Harriet Tubman: the Underground Railroad.

Between 1959 and 1972, 44 black players made that trip north, from every part of the segregated South except Alabama, Tennessee and Maryland. By 1962 the Associated Press was already calling Michigan State’s 17 black players the largest such group in the history of major college football. By 1966 it was 20 on a 67-man roster.

And in September 1964, Daugherty took his team south — to Kenan Stadium in Chapel Hill, with a fully integrated roster, on southern soil. Twenty-four years earlier NYU students had needed picket signs and a boycott threat just to keep one black player from being benched. Daugherty didn’t ask permission. He showed up with the whole team.

Those rosters produced some of the most decorated players in the sport’s history. Bubba Smith, a defensive end out of Beaumont, Texas, whose own father — a high school coach — helped run players north. Gene Washington, also out of Texas. George Webster, a linebacker from Anderson, South Carolina, who some contemporaries thought should have won the 1966 Heisman outright. Clinton Jones out of Cleveland. And Jimmy Raye out of Fayetteville, North Carolina, who in 1966 became the first black quarterback from the South to start for and win a national championship — a job he legally could not have held at most flagship universities back home.

That 1966 team tied Notre Dame 10-10 in the game the press called the Game of the Century, watched by 33 million people, the largest television audience for a sporting event to that point. Both teams ended up sharing the national title. Michigan State started a dozen black players that day.

Raye said later that when his mother weighed sending him to Michigan State, football barely entered into it. She wanted to know if he’d actually get his degree. Once he got there, black students numbered only a couple hundred out of a campus of tens of thousands, and by his own account they mostly stuck together. Getting out of the segregated South didn’t mean landing in an integrated anywhere.

Raye’s mother, it turns out, had nothing to worry about. Of the 44 players who rode the Underground Railroad between 1959 and 1972, 30 of them — roughly 68% — graduated. Twenty years later, in 1984, the national graduation rate for black college football players had fallen to about 30%, which is part of why the NCAA eventually imposed stricter academic eligibility rules in the first place. Daugherty wasn’t just moving talent north. He was running one of the only programs in the country where a black athlete’s degree was treated as seriously as his 40 time.

The NFL noticed the talent, too. At the 1967 draft, four members of a single 1963 recruiting class — Smith, Jones, Webster and Washington — were selected among the first eight picks. Smith went first overall to Baltimore. No program had ever produced a haul like that, and every one of those four had been told at some point back home that there simply wasn’t room for him.

The South Moves

Southern programs started moving because they were watching too much talent walk out the back door and beat them with it. Bubba Smith put it plainly years later: losing changed minds, guilt never did.

They moved slowly and unevenly and only when the drain got embarrassing. In 1965 Jerry LeVias signed with SMU, the first black scholarship football player in the entire Southwest Conference. He drew death threats serious enough that city, state and federal officers had to watch for snipers before one road game.

In 1966 — the same year Michigan State’s fully integrated roster was winning a share of the national championship — the Southeastern Conference finally signed its first two black players anywhere in the league: Greg Page and Nate Northington, both at Kentucky. Page never got to play a down. He was paralyzed in a preseason practice collision in August 1967, spent 38 days in a coma, and died that September. Northington played on alone, the only black player in the entire SEC for most of that season.

That’s the actual distance between the two stories. In East Lansing, 20 black players on a national championship team. One conference south, the whole SEC had two — and one of them didn’t survive to take the field.

Where Are We Now

Jackson took the field at Amherst in 1889 as one man alone, hoping talent would be enough. For most of the next 80 years it wasn’t. Programs let in one player, maybe two, called it progress, and moved on.

Today black athletes make up roughly 40% of major college football rosters. In the NFL it’s a clear majority — over 53% by the league’s own most recent count. Daugherty’s 1966 championship team, with 20 black players out of 67, was radical enough to make the AP wire. By today’s numbers that roster wouldn’t be exceptional. It would be slightly below average.

Flippin, Jewett, Jackson and Lewis proved it could be done. It took Daugherty’s generation — and the black high school coaches across the South who built his pipeline for him — to prove it could be done at scale. And once that was proven, the rest of the sport ran out of excuses.

More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos