JD PicKell’s 9-3 Texas A&M Prediction Feels Like a Failure

NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...

Texas A&M football is about to leave prediction season behind. Before Mike Elko’s Aggies hit the practice field, however, On3’s J.D. PicKell dropped a 9-3 forecast that would produce several unforgettable Saturdays and possibly one deeply disappointing ending.

PicKell, who was one of Texas A&M’s loudest national believers before its first College Football Playoff appearance, doesn’t expect Elko’s third team to match last season’s 11-2 record.

MORE: Texas A&M Opens Fall Camp With CFP Pressure at Full Blast

His concern isn’t necessarily the roster. It’s a savage road schedule featuring LSU, Missouri, Alabama, South Carolina and Oklahoma. Texas A&M’s official schedule confirms five SEC trips, including late-season games at South Carolina and Oklahoma.

According to PicKell’s On3 prediction, the Aggies open 3-0 by handling Missouri State, Arizona State and Kentucky at Kyle Field. That’s the comfortable part.

Then comes Baton Rouge.

Texas A&M destroyed LSU 49-25 on the road last season, but PicKell doesn’t see that happening again. With Lane Kiffin now leading the Tigers, he projects a close LSU victory that hands Marcel Reed and the Aggies their first loss.

A&M responds by beating Arkansas and Missouri before PicKell delivers his boldest call: Texas A&M walks into Tuscaloosa and beats Alabama.

That result would put the Aggies at 6-1 and squarely in the playoff race. It would also make what PicKell predicts next hurt even more.

South Carolina blew a 30-3 halftime lead at Kyle Field last season, eventually watching Texas A&M complete a humiliating comeback. PicKell expects the Gamecocks to return the favor at Williams-Brice Stadium, dropping A&M to 6-2.

Wins over The Citadel and Tennessee would restore order before another road test derails the season. PicKell has Oklahoma beating the Aggies in Norman, leaving A&M at 8-3 entering the Lone Star Showdown.

Then comes the twist.

PicKell predicts Texas A&M will beat Texas at Kyle Field for the first time since the Longhorns joined the SEC. That would deliver Elko a rivalry-defining win and send the Aggies into postseason selection weekend at 9-3.

On3 has previously featured PicKell’s analysis of Texas A&M’s 2026 win total and outlook.

Beating Alabama and Texas in the same season should feel enormous. Missing the playoff anyway wouldn’t.

MORE: Ex Aggies Wideout Is Turning Bengals Camp Into His NFL Redemption Shot

With Reed returning and Texas A&M carrying talent and depth across the roster, 9-3 would be respectable. It could also feel like a wasted opportunity.

That’s the brutal reality facing Elko in 2026: the Aggies are good enough that merely being good may no longer count as success.

More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos