Why Iowa Will, and Will Not, Win at Michigan
NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...
After three weeks of tune-ups and one legitimate scare, the training wheels come all the way off for the Iowa Hawkeyes on Saturday afternoon in Ann Arbor.
The #17 Hawkeyes and #18 Wolverines are mirror images on paper. Both are 3-0. Both are built on defense. Both have exactly one win over a real opponent and both have fanbases squinting at the offense wondering what exactly they have. One of them leaves Michigan Stadium with a playoff resume win and a Big Ten opener in the bank. The other gets to spend a week hearing about it while their playoff path becomes more narrow.
Some locally have called this Iowa’s biggest game since the top-5 Penn State showdown in 2021 and it’s hard to argue in the regular season. So let’s do what we do and argue with ourselves instead. Why Iowa loses this game, why they win it and what the fanbase thinks about the whole thing.
Why Iowa Will Not Win
Start with the ghosts. Iowa has lost nine consecutive games played in front of 100,000+ fans and the last win in such an environment came at the Big House back in 2010. It gets worse. The Hawkeyes have gone 44 straight possessions in 100,000-seat stadiums without so much as a trip to the red zone. There will be 107,000+ waiting on Saturday, and the quarterback leading Iowa into that noise has never started a road game at the collegiate level. Not at Auburn, not last year, not ever. Hank Brown’s first one comes in the largest stadium in the country with massive implications.
Then there’s the matchup problem. Michigan brings a top-10 total defense allowing just 220 yards per game, and the run defense numbers are legitimately scary 2.7 yards per carry allowed and zero rushing touchdowns surrendered through three games. PFF grades their defensive line as the best in the country, with edge John Henry Daley leading the way with 2.5 sacks. The one time Iowa played a defense anywhere near this caliber, the ground game managed 93 yards against Iowa State and the offense needed a walk-off field goal to escape despite being massive favorites.
Every preview out of Michigan this week says the same thing: they intend to strangle the run and make Brown beat them with his arm in that environment. That’s not a secret plan. It’s just a good one.
Finally, there’s the resume gap. Iowa’s gaudy season numbers were built on NIU, UNI and a white-knuckle rivalry win over the Cyclones. Michigan has the only ranked win after bouncing back from their WMU debacle with a 17-10 win over Oklahoma. Then they bounced back after a rough start vs UTEP to put up a legit offensive output that should be reason for concern.
The folks in the desert have noticed – Michigan is favored by 5.5 at FanDuel Sportsbook after the line opened at 4.5, and ESPN’s matchup predictor gives the Wolverines a 65% chance to win. The beat writers are nearly unanimous too. Chad Leistikow called it 17-13 Michigan. Our own staff at The Pants went 5-2 in favor of the Wolverines.
Why Iowa Will Win
Now the good news: Bryce Underwood has put the ball on the ground in every game this season. Michigan has fumbled six times through three games and lost four of them and the Wolverines sit 104th nationally in turnover margin at minus-2. Iowa is 23rd at plus-3. Phil Parker has spent 15 years turning talented young quarterbacks into mistakes and he gets a sophomore with a live arm, happy feet and a ball-security problem in a game where every possession is gold. If Iowa wins, this is why.
Reason two? This Iowa offense is not the 2023 group that got shut out in Indianapolis, no matter how many times CBS shows that highlight this afternoon. Brown is completing 72.6% of his passes on the season, something no Iowa quarterback has done through three games, with 473 yards, three scores and zero turnovers. Tony Diaz has been the best receiver on the field every week he’s played.
And the offensive line that won the Joe Moore Award gets the heavyweight matchup with Michigan’s front – strength on strength, with a 268-yards-per-game rushing attack behind it. Kirk Ferentz put it plainly this week: there’s more octane in the tank than there was in 2023. Meanwhile Michigan’s offense ranks 118th nationally in total yardage and scored 13 and 17 in its two real games. If Iowa finds 20, Michigan may simply not have the horses to chase it.
Finally, Michigan is banged up in exactly the wrong places. Their Friday availability report lists starting-caliber offensive linemen Andrew Babalola out and Andrew Sprague questionable, with their sixth-lineman package doubtful. Edge Dominic Nichols is questionable. Running back Jordan Marshall isn’t on the report but isn’t 100% either, per his own head coach.
Add a special teams edge – Boston Everitt is averaging 44.1 per punt with nine inside the 20 and Caden Buhr has made five of six with a game-winner already banked – and the rock fight math starts tilting toward the team that plays clean and flips the field. Don’t take my word for it. Take Kyle Whittingham’s: “They shorten the game and beat you with defense and win it at the end.” That’s the scouting report from the other sideline.
The Fanbase Isn’t Buying the Spread
All of that brings us to this week’s Reacts poll. We asked a simple question: will Iowa win at Michigan? A whopping 71% of you said yes.
That’s a fanbase picking a road underdog getting 5.5 points to win outright, at a stadium where the program hasn’t won in 16 years. Bold? Sure. But the optimists have some company. While the print predictions run heavily Michigan, the TV crews leaned the other way this week, with a majority of both the CBS and FOX pregame panels taking the Hawkeyes. At +180 on the moneyline, 71% of the fanbase has a chance to make some money today.
More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos