Deion Sanders Benched Julian Lewis, Then Said “It Didn’t Happen Like That.” So What Did?
NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...
Something is going on between Deion Sanders and Julian Lewis, and Colorado had better sort it out fast.
Lewis opened the season as the Buffaloes’ starting quarterback. Earlier this season, he threw for 366 yards and four touchdowns against Weber State. On Saturday night, the former five-star recruit didn’t take a single snap in Colorado’s 29-7 loss to Texas Tech.
He apparently wasn’t even QB2.
Isaac Wilson got the start, and Kaneal Sweetwyne was the other quarterback Colorado put on the field. Lewis watched from the sideline as Wilson threw three interceptions and the Buffaloes dropped their third straight game.
Then Coach Prime stepped to the podium and made things a whole lot more interesting.
“I would love for JuJu to come in here and he tells you what happened,” Sanders told reporters. “You bench JuJu to third or second string? No, that’s not how it all went down.”
And then the line that set off every alarm in Boulder:
“It didn’t happen like that.”
OK, Deion. Then how did it happen?
He isn’t saying, and Lewis hasn’t explained it publicly either. What is obvious is that Colorado has a quarterback problem, and Sanders is playing a risky game with the player who was supposed to be the future of his program.
Julian Lewis’ stunning fall from Colorado QB1
Lewis’ slide happened fast.
The 19-year-old started Colorado’s first four games after being tabbed as Shedeur Sanders’ heir apparent last season. He showed exactly why the hype was real when he shredded Weber State for 366 passing yards and four touchdowns, then added another score on the ground. That performance earned him Big 12 Freshman of the Week.
A few weeks later, he was out of the lineup entirely.
The trouble started against Baylor on Sept. 26. Lewis struggled in the first half, and Sanders went to Wilson after halftime. That cracked the quarterback competition wide open heading into Texas Tech, and Sanders picked Wilson.
That call was defensible. What came next is a lot harder to explain.
Wilson went 26 of 44 for 290 yards and a touchdown against the Red Raiders, but he also threw three picks, including one returned for a touchdown. Colorado scored on its opening drive and never scored again.
Lewis still never got in. Neither did a functioning offense.
The Buffaloes have scored 27 points combined during the three-game skid. They sit at 2-3 heading into the bye, with No. 12 Utah waiting on Oct. 17.
Sanders, to his credit, isn’t pretending things are fine.
“We’ve been horrible,” he said after the Texas Tech loss. “I won’t sugarcoat it.”
He was just as blunt about where the biggest problem lives.
“We have one glaring problem,” Sanders said. “We have to play better at one specific position.”
He didn’t have to name it. Everybody knows it’s quarterback.
Deion Sanders says Colorado’s QB battle is wide open
Sanders said the competition will carry on through the bye week.
“We have three options there,” he said. “Somebody just has to grab a hold of it and get it done.”
Fair enough. Lewis hasn’t played well enough to be handed the job, and Wilson hasn’t either. If Sanders thinks Sweetwyne has earned a look, give him one. Competition is supposed to be the backbone of big-time college football.
But making Lewis earn the job is one thing. Letting the relationship with one of the most important young players in the program go sideways is something else entirely, and that’s where Colorado needs to tread carefully.
Lewis isn’t some veteran transfer playing out the string. He was one of the biggest recruiting wins of the Sanders era, the guy Colorado was counting on to carry the program into its next chapter. The Buffaloes spent two seasons building around Shedeur Sanders, and Lewis was supposed to be the next quarterback they could build around.
Right now, nobody outside the building seems to know where he stands.
Why the transfer portal changes everything for Coach Prime
There was a time when Sanders could have handled this however he pleased. Bench Lewis, drop him to third string, sit him for a month and see how he responds.
That isn’t college football anymore.
The transfer portal shifted the leverage between coaches and quarterbacks, and NIL and revenue sharing shifted it even further. Quarterbacks don’t have to sit around and wait for their shot, especially not ones with Lewis’ pedigree.
Lewis was one of the most coveted recruits in the country before he picked Colorado. He reclassified from the 2026 class to 2025 and showed up in Boulder as one of the most recognizable young quarterbacks in the sport.
If he decides Colorado no longer sees him as its future, there will be no shortage of programs ready to tell him they do.
None of that means Sanders should start Lewis out of fear he’ll bolt. That would be ridiculous, and players still have to earn their jobs. But Colorado does need to decide whether it’s developing Lewis, challenging him or moving on from him.
At the moment, nobody seems sure which one it is.
Colorado can’t afford to waste Julian Lewis
Sanders deserves some credit for refusing to throw his young quarterback under the bus after the Texas Tech loss. When reporters kept pressing him about Lewis, he pushed back.
“JuJu didn’t play today,” he said. “I’m not going to badger the kid or say nothing derogatory for the kid.”
That’s a reasonable stance. The problem is that Sanders also hinted there was another explanation for Lewis’ absence and then refused to share it. Maybe there’s a perfectly good reason. Until Lewis or Colorado actually gives one, that’s all anyone can responsibly say.
The football side is simpler. Colorado needs better quarterback play, period.
Wilson didn’t deliver it against Texas Tech. Lewis hadn’t delivered enough of it before getting pulled against Baylor. Sweetwyne hasn’t shown he’s the answer.
That’s what the bye week is for. Open it up, make all three earn it, and roll with whoever gives Colorado the best shot against Utah.
But if that guy isn’t Lewis, Sanders and his staff had better have a clear plan for what comes next. There’s a big difference between benching your young quarterback and losing him for good.
Colorado can survive the first one. The second could haunt the Buffaloes long after this rough season is over.
Related Headlines
- Iowa Football Can Still Make Run to Big Ten Championship
- Iowa State Star Aiden Flora: The Best Unknown Player
- Jeremiah Smith is The Best Player in College Football
More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos