Florida’s early-season optimism gives way to sobering reality | 5 things we learned from South Carolina loss
NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...
GAINESVILLE — Florida’s second-half homecoming collapse against South Carolina magnified the shortcomings revealed a week earlier at Missouri. The Gators followed their meteoric rise into the top 10 with two lopsided losses that will knock first-year coach Jon Sumrall’s team out of the Top 25.
Here are five things we learned from Saturday’s 38-19 loss to the Gamecocks.
CFP hopes gone; Gators back to square one
Entering the season, eight wins appeared to be the Gators’ best-case scenario and a significant improvement over a 4-8 record in 2025.
Routing Ole Miss and rising to No. 8 in the national rankings accelerated expectations, setting up Florida for a fall. Sumrall now must prevent it from becoming a free fall.
A visit to Texas already loomed as a Herculean challenge, but the top-ranked Longhorns (4-1, 1-1 SEC) will be smarting from a 27-24 loss to unranked rival Oklahoma.
The Gators (4-2, 2-2) will run into another buzzsaw unless their offensive line generates push in the run game and gives quarterback Aaron Philo time to operate. South Carolina’s LaNorris Sellers threw four touchdown passes, further exposing Florida’s inconsistent pass rush and leaky secondary.
Another double-digit loss would continue Florida’s sudden slide.
Vernell Brown III needs to get back on the field
Florida’s star receiver practiced Friday but was not 100% after suffering a knee injury against Ole Miss.
Brown lacked the confidence to “cut it loose,” prompting the speedy sophomore to sit out against South Carolina after not playing versus Missouri.
“He’s closer, hopefully,” Sumrall said. “He’s cleared to do as much as he can and feels confident in right now.”
Brown’s absence the past two games has been glaring.
He’s a threat to turn a screen pass into a score. Brown accelerates off the line of scrimmage and creates separation unlike any Florida receiver. He’s also a weapon as a punt returner.
Bailey Stockton admirably filled the void against South Carolina, finishing with a career-high eight receptions for 127 yards, including a 59-yard touchdown for Florida’s first points.
Stockton’s performance comes two weeks after a brutal collision between two Ole Miss defenders sent him to the sidelines with a sore back and seeing stars.
“I was knocked out,” he said after Saturday’s loss.
Stockton, though, was determined to return, even if not 100%.
“I’m banged up, but the team needs to win,” he said. “The more players that play, it’s a better opportunity for that to happen.”
Brown’s return would improve the Gators’ odds.
A disappointing finish is suddenly in play
Losses at Texas and Oct. 31 in Atlanta against Georgia were already penciled in by many. Missouri was a toss-up. Beating Ole Miss was a bonus.
But few expected South Carolina to dominate Florida in the Swamp. The loss makes every remaining game a question mark.
A potential 4-4 record with Oklahoma visiting Nov. 7 and a Nov. 14 trip to Kentucky could leave Florida fighting to finish .500 and qualify for a bowl.
Flashbacks to the Billy Napier era
Like Napier’s teams, the margin for error is slim for Sumrall’s squad.
Against South Carolina, the Gators settled for field goals, played too conservatively closing the first half and had three turnovers against a defense that had forced just two in five games.
Consider red-zone opportunities. The Gators entered Saturday converting 81% of their chances into touchdowns (21 of 26). But on fourth-and-goal from the Gamecocks’ 3-yard line, Florida settled for a 21-yard field goal.
Trailing 17-10 to open the second half and facing third-and-5, the Gators ran the ball from the South Carolina 27 and lost three yards, settling for three points again.
Between those field goals by Patrick Durkin, Florida had a chance to cut into the lead. With 1:40 left in the first half and three timeouts, Florida ran four plays for 10 yards before calling a timeout with 21 seconds to go. Durkin eventually missed a 43-yard attempt, prompting a homecoming crowd to shower the Gators with boos.
Sumrall said he opted for a more conservative approach because an Aaron Philo interception had set up South Carolina’s previous touchdown.
“Did not want to give them an opportunity, with us backed up, to possess the football on a shorter field and have an opportunity at a field goal,” Sumrall explained.
Winning teams are bold — but given Florida’s offensive line issues, Sumrall chose to play it safe.
Right tackle is an issue
Sophomore Stanford transfer Emeka Ugori’s move from guard to tackle has come with considerable growing pains.
On Saturday, South Carolina star edge rusher Dylan Stewart terrorized him while finishing with a sack and two forced fumbles. One came when Stewart stripped quarterback Aaron Philo with 12:58 remaining and Florida trailing 31-13 at the Gamecocks’ 17-yard line.
When Ugori left the game briefly after being banged up, veteran Caden Jones replaced him. Jadan Baugh ripped off a 26-yard run to the right side on Florida’s opening drive of the second half, but coaches reinserted Ugori on the next series, suggesting they have little confidence in Jones, a 10-game starter in 2025.
Florida’s O-line has struggled the past two games, particularly at right tackle. The Gators have yet to find a reliable solution at a position that remains a glaring weakness.
Edgar Thompson can be reached at egthompson@orlandosentinel.com
Up next
What: UF (4-2, 2-2 SEC) at Texas (4-1, 1-1)
When: 12 p.m., Saturday
Where:Darrell K Royal–Texas Memorial Stadium, Austin
TV: ABC/ESPN
Favorite: Texas by 8.5 points
More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos