Keelon Russell Projected to Win Alabama QB Job, But Crimson Tide Can’t Lose With Either Choice

NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos...

The quarterback battle in Tuscaloosa might finally be starting to lean in one direction.

Maybe.

According to the latest buzz surrounding Alabama’s quarterback competition, former five-star quarterback Keelon Russell is being projected to emerge as the Crimson Tide’s starting quarterback for the 2026 season over Austin Mack.

Pete Nakos of On3 recently reported that sources who watched Alabama’s scrimmage felt both quarterbacks had strong moments, but Russell was the quarterback making some of the more noticeable plays. Nakos also noted that has largely been the story throughout camp: Mack has consistently stacked together good days, while Russell has produced those moments where his talent simply jumps off the field.

And if Russell ultimately wins this job, nobody should be shocked.

But I also think we need to be careful about turning a quarterback competition into something it isn't. This does not have to become a story about Keelon Russell being great and Austin Mack somehow failing.

Actually, I think it is almost the exact opposite. If Russell beats Mack for Alabama’s starting quarterback job, it might tell us just how special Russell has become.

Because Mack is a really good quarterback. Remember, Mack was a four-star prospect who originally signed with Washington after reclassifying from the 2024 recruiting class into 2023. He then followed Kalen DeBoer from Washington to Alabama and has now spent multiple years learning DeBoer’s offensive system.

That's important. Mack isn't some random quarterback Alabama grabbed out of the transfer portal to fill out its depth chart.

He knows this offense. He knows DeBoer. He understands what is expected of the quarterback in this system, and by virtually every report coming out of camp, Mack has played good football. That is why Russell potentially beating him out should get Alabama fans excited.

Really excited.

Russell came to Alabama with massive expectations. That happens when you are one of the best quarterback prospects in the country. Russell was a five-star recruit coming out of Duncanville High School in Texas and was named the 2024 Gatorade National Football Player of the Year. Before arriving in Tuscaloosa, he had already proven he could handle pressure, expectations and winning at an incredibly high level.

But recruiting rankings only matter for so long.

Eventually you have to prove it. Eventually five stars beside your name become irrelevant. Eventually you have to walk onto Alabama’s practice field and beat somebody. And that is what makes this quarterback competition so fascinating.

Russell wasn't handed anything. He spent last season developing behind Ty Simpson. Mack was there too. Both quarterbacks had an opportunity to learn, grow, watch and prepare while Simpson led Alabama’s offense.

Now Simpson is gone and already beginning his NFL career, and Alabama has another quarterback decision to make.

Except this doesn't feel like a quarterback room desperately searching for an answer. It feels like a quarterback room trying to choose between two really good ones. There is a huge difference.

Recent reporting has suggested Russell has flashed the kind of playmaking ability that is difficult to ignore. After Alabama’s scrimmage, observers reportedly came away impressed with his ability to create and make plays, while Mack continued to show the consistency that has made this battle so competitive. That sounds exactly like the type of competition Alabama should want.

Mack gives you experience in the system, consistency, size and familiarity. Russell gives you explosiveness, athleticism, tremendous upside and that undeniable ability to make something happen. Good luck choosing. And I mean that in the best possible way.

I've said this before when talking about Alabama’s quarterbacks, but I think it deserves repeating: one of the biggest victories for Kalen DeBoer happened before he ever named QB1.

He got both of these guys to stay. Think about college football right now. Think about the transfer portal. Think about NIL. Think about how quickly quarterbacks leave the second they believe someone else might be standing between them and the starting job.

Russell could have looked around the country and almost certainly found programs willing to promise him an opportunity.

Mack could have done the same thing.

Instead, both stayed at Alabama.

Both competed. Both believed enough in DeBoer, Ryan Grubb and what Alabama is building to battle for the job instead of looking for an easier path somewhere else.

That matters.

A lot.

We spend so much time discussing who will win quarterback competitions that sometimes we miss how impressive it is to have a legitimate competition at all. Alabama has two quarterbacks who could probably start for a lot of college football programs.

Only one can run onto the field first. And right now, the momentum appears to be building around Russell. But nothing has officially been decided.

College football analyst Josh Pate recently described the competition as extremely close and pushed back against the idea that Russell has simply run away with the job.

That's another important piece of this story. A projection is not a depth chart. Camp buzz is not an announcement. And until Kalen DeBoer names his starting quarterback, I'm not going to pretend this thing is over.

But I will say this: If Russell is legitimately pushing past a quarterback as talented and experienced in this system as Mack, then Alabama may have something incredibly special developing.

Russell has always had the talent. Now we're beginning to hear about the development. That's the part that excites me.

The jump from talented young quarterback to SEC starting quarterback isn't small.

You have to command the huddle. You have to understand protections. You have to process defenses. You have to take care of the football. You have to make the boring play when the boring play is the correct play. And then, when everything breaks down, sometimes you have to make the kind of play that reminds everyone why you were a five-star quarterback in the first place.

That's where Russell can be dangerous.

There are quarterbacks who execute an offense. Then there are quarterbacks capable of changing a game. Russell has the physical tools to become the latter.

The question has always been when the rest of his game would catch up.

Maybe we're watching that happen right now. Still, Alabama fans should not make the mistake of tearing down Mack because Russell appears to have momentum.

I hate when quarterback competitions become that. One guy doesn't have to stink for the other guy to be good. Mack can be a really good quarterback and Russell can still beat him. Actually, if Russell wins this job because he legitimately outperformed Mack, I think that should make Alabama fans feel even better about Russell.

He earned it. And if Mack ultimately wins the job? My opinion of Alabama’s quarterback room doesn't suddenly change. Alabama is still in good hands.

That is the biggest takeaway from all of this.

We don't know yet whether Alabama will open the season with No. 12 or No. 10 running the offense. We don't know what DeBoer and Grubb will ultimately decide when every practice, scrimmage, meeting and rep is evaluated. But we know Alabama has options. Really good options. That hasn't always been appreciated enough.

Russell represents the future everyone has been waiting to see. The five-star quarterback from Texas. The enormous upside. The playmaker. The guy Alabama fans have imagined taking over this offense since the day he committed.

Mack represents something valuable too.

Development. Patience. Experience. Loyalty. And years spent inside DeBoer’s system.

This isn't choosing between a quarterback Alabama trusts and one Alabama doesn't. It appears to be choosing between two quarterbacks the coaching staff believes can win. That's a problem every program in America would love to have.

And there is another part of this that excites me.

Whoever wins this job will have earned it.

Nothing was promised. Nothing was handed over because of recruiting ranking, age or seniority. Russell isn't going to become QB1 simply because he was a five-star prospect. Mack isn't going to become QB1 simply because he has been in DeBoer’s system longer. They have to compete. That's how Alabama should be.

The best player plays. Period.

And if the reports are correct and Russell is beginning to separate himself, then hand him the football and see what the kid can do.

Because the talent is undeniable. The ceiling is enormous. And if the mental part of his game has developed enough to match all those physical gifts, Alabama could have one of college football’s next breakout quarterbacks sitting in Tuscaloosa.

But I'm not counting Mack out until DeBoer tells us the competition is over.

Not after everything we've heard about how consistent he has been. Not after the time he has spent developing inside this offense. Not when the people actually following this competition closely continue to describe it as competitive. And maybe that's what Alabama fans should enjoy most about the next few weeks.

We don't have to panic about who wins. We can be excited about whoever does.

If it's Keelon Russell, Alabama may be watching the beginning of the career everyone envisioned when that five-star quarterback chose the Crimson Tide.

If it's Austin Mack, it means he fought off one of the most talented young quarterbacks in America to earn the job.

Either outcome says something good about Alabama. Kalen DeBoer has built a quarterback room with competition, talent and legitimate depth at the most important position on the field. Now he has to choose.

Russell may be the projected favorite. Mack may still have something to say about it.

But regardless of whether Alabama ultimately names Keelon Russell or Austin Mack QB1, I feel really good about one thing:

Alabama is in good hands.

Roll Tide. 

More at NCAAF College Football News, Photos, Stats, Scores, Schedule & Videos